I’ve been hearing rumblings for a while now that Twitter has been unfollowing people from anti-establishment accounts, and some of my readers have told me
they’ve been unfollowed from me, so I’ve been keeping an eye on it but
my follower account appeared to be growing normally. That changed about
36 hours ago as of this writing, when I came back from an absurd
week-long suspension for calling a group of people “stupid” and “dumb”
who had tagged me in a post calling me a Nazi.
Now, this has been going on with Facebook for months already.
My Facebook page following, which used to add many people every day,
has been frozen on the same number of followers for days now as people
are automatically unfollowed as fast as they follow. This phenomenon is
common knowledge among dissident voices already; Lee Camp of Redacted
Tonight tweeted
in January, “In case anyone wants to know how Face book suppression
works — I have 330,000 followers there but they’ve stopped showing my
posts to many ppl. I used to gain 6,000 followers a week. I now gain 500
and FB unsubscribes ppl w/out their knowledge — so my total numbr never
increases.”
This has been happening on Youtube as well, with crucial anti-establishment voices like Jimmy Dore reporting that people are being automatically unfollowed from their channels.
Now
it looks like it might be happening with Twitter as well. I’m just
going to lay out the evidence I have so that everyone has access to the
information and can piece together what’s going on. We already know that
Twitter CEO Jack Dorsey will brazenly lie to us about his site’s
censorship practices, since he got caught lying
about censoring the #DNCLeaks hashtag in 2016, so we’ve got to share
information and figure out what’s going on for ourselves. It’s important
for us all to put as much information out there as possible.
While
Facebook has been throttling my following for ages, my Twitter
following has always grown unimpeded ever since I started using it
regularly to share my work and ideas. Even when I was suspended for a
week I added somewhere between 100 and 200 followers. Ever since I came
back, though, my following has been kept steadily between 26,855 and
26,858. I keep getting notifications of new followers, and when I look I
see those new followers are indeed there, but for the last 36 hours my
numbers haven’t increased with the new followers added, which makes me
suspect that people are being unfollowed as new follows come in in order
to slow or stop my growth on social media.
This
could all be a temporary fluke, but it’s definitely a big change from
what was happening, and it’s definitely not just me experiencing this; I
tweeted about it asking if others are having the same issue and
received a ton of answers in the affirmative. Check out the responses in
this thread if you’re curious.
Anyway,
here’s what I’ve got. I took a bunch of screen shots, then took screen
shots of those screen shots so you can see the time in which I took
them. Don’t make fun of my weird sleep patterns.
So
at 6:38 PM last night, when I hovered my cursor over my number of
followers I got 26,858, which the display rounds up to 26.9K.
Hello,
new follower in my notifications two minutes later! It always displays
the newest followers on the left; when I hover my curser over the
account on the farthest left I get this Walton guy here, and when I
check the “followers” section on my account he’s on the top left where
he should be. This will all be familiar to regular Twitter users; I’m
just laying this out for people who don’t know their way around it very
well.
But check out what happened when I checked my follower count twenty minutes later:
What the hell?
At
9:39 PM I got another notification about this new follower, who when I
check my followers list appears to the left of the Walton guy. But when I
check my follower count:
Why isn’t it going up?
Again, at 11:55 PM, two new followers:
And what happened to my follower count? It went down one.
Crap, make that two:
Let’s check my notifications again at 3:56 AM (don’t make fun):
Ooh!
Lotsa new friends! When I check my followers list, I can see the last
guy who followed on my last count in the bottom-right corner, with eight
new followers added since he joined:
But what happened to my follower count? Increased by only three.
After
adding a total of twelve followers since I started counting, I’m back
to the same number of followers as when I started counting.
Oops, make that one less.
This
has never happened to me before. My follower count has always
immediately risen in proportion to my new followers. I’ve always gained
followers steadily, losing a few here and there, gaining large numbers
suddenly when I do something particularly awesome and losing large
numbers when I say something particularly controversial. Never before
have I gained followers steadily with my numbers being kept around the
same point.
Again, readers have told me that they’ve been unfollowed from me in the past against their will:
And
it’s still going on this morning. I’ve added 14 followers since my last
count (26 total since I started counting), but it only has me up six
from when I started counting.
So
that’s really weird. Twitter appears to be doing what Facebook and
Youtube have been doing in the wake of increasing demand that they make
changes in the way their platforms operate “to prevent the fomenting of
discord,” as they were asked to do on the Senate floor a few months ago.
Or
maybe they’re not? Who knows? Maybe there’s some other explanation. All
I know is that this has never happened to me before, that other people
are complaining about the same problem, that Jack Dorsey lies
about Twitter’s censorship of anti-establishment material, and that we
all benefit from sharing this kind of information with each other. So
for any journalists or anyone else out there trying to piece together
what’s going on, here’s what’s going on on my end.
I
encourage everyone to share the details of their fishy censorship
experiences using screen shots with time stamps as I have done here.
These bastards won’t tell us how they’re manipulating us, so we’ve got
to figure it out ourselves.
Remember:
in a corporatist system of government, where there is no meaningful
separation between corporate power and government power, corporate
censorship is government censorship. It is not okay for them to do this
to us. It is not okay for them to stop people from communicating with
each other about the powerful forces which rule them. Keep fighting.
Rubén Weinsteiner
Rubén Weinsteiner
